Top-Rated Shark & Tarpon Fishing Key West

Night Sharks & Tarpon: Key West After Dark

Ready for a fishing trip that'll get your heart racing? Our 4-hour evening shark and tarpon adventure in Key West's backcountry waters is just the ticket. As the sun dips below the horizon, we'll hit the water in search of some of Florida's most exciting gamefish. This isn't your average day on the boat – it's a chance to tangle with some real monsters under the cover of darkness.

Trip Overview

We kick off at 4 PM, just as the day crowds are heading in. Our 22' Lake and Bay boat is perfect for sneaking into those backwater haunts where the big boys like to hang out. We're talking channels, bridges, and hidden spots that light up with activity as night falls. It's just you and up to three buddies on this private charter, so we can tailor the experience to your group's skill level. Whether you're seasoned anglers or first-timers, we'll make sure you're in on the action.

Night Fishing 101

Once we're out there, it's all about live bait and light tackle. We're not messing around with heavy gear – this is about feeling every head shake and run. We'll be targeting tarpon in the 20 to 50 pound range, but don't be surprised if something bigger decides to crash the party. Alongside the silver kings, we'll be on the lookout for some toothy critters. Shark fishing at night adds a whole new level of excitement to the mix. And for those who like a little variety, we'll also try our luck with some chunky mangrove snapper.

Why Anglers Can't Get Enough

There's something special about fishing after the sun goes down. The water takes on a different vibe, and the fish seem to get bolder. Our regulars keep coming back for that heart-stopping moment when a big tarpon goes airborne, silhouetted against the night sky. Or the unmistakable pull of a shark on the line, testing your gear and your nerves. It's not just fishing – it's an adrenaline rush you can't find anywhere else in Key West.

Target Species Breakdown

Tarpon: These silver-sided bruisers are the stars of the show. Known as the "silver king," tarpon in Key West can range from scrappy 20-pounders to real monsters pushing 100 pounds or more. They're famous for their acrobatic leaps and powerful runs. The cooler evening temperatures often bring them closer to the surface, making for some explosive topwater action. Tarpon fishing is catch-and-release, but trust me, the memories of battling these prehistoric powerhouses will stick with you long after you've let them go.

Blacktip Shark: These speed demons of the shark world are a blast to catch. Blacktips are known for their quick runs and aerial displays – yeah, sharks that jump! They typically range from 3 to 6 feet long in our waters. Blacktips tend to hunt in packs, so when you find one, there's usually more nearby. They're most active at dusk and dawn, making them perfect targets for our evening trips.

Lemon Shark: Don't let the name fool you – these guys are all business. Lemon sharks are stocky, powerful fish that can grow up to 10 feet long. They're not as quick as blacktips, but what they lack in speed they make up for in raw power. Lemon sharks love hanging around the bridges and channels we fish, especially as the tide starts moving. Hooking into one of these bruisers will test your arms and your drag system.

Bull Shark: The heavyweights of our inshore shark fishing, bull sharks are the ones that really get the blood pumping. These thick-bodied predators can top 8 feet in length and are known for their aggressive runs and dogged fights. Bull sharks are ambush predators, often lurking in deeper holes or along channel edges. When one of these decides to eat your bait, hold on tight – it's going to be a wild ride.

What to Expect on the Water

As we push off from the dock, the setting sun paints the sky in a riot of colors – your first photo op of the night. We'll cruise out to our fishing grounds, keeping an eye out for rolling tarpon or the telltale signs of feeding fish. Once we're set up, it's all hands on deck. We'll get lines in the water and start working different areas, always on the move to stay on the fish.

The beauty of night fishing is how your other senses kick in. You'll hear the splash of a tarpon busting bait or feel the subtle tap of a shark investigating your offering. When that rod doubles over, it's game on. The fights can be intense, especially when you can't see what's on the other end. But don't worry – our experienced crew will be right there to guide you through every step.

Time to Book Your Spot

Look, I could go on all day about the rush of hooking into a big tarpon or the thrill of battling a shark under the stars. But words only go so far – you've got to experience this for yourself. Our 4-hour evening shark and tarpon trips are some of the most popular charters we offer, and spots fill up fast. At $799 for a private trip for up to four people, it's a steal for a night of fishing you'll be talking about for years to come. So what are you waiting for? Grab your crew, book your trip, and get ready for some serious after-dark action on the waters of Key West. Trust me, once you've felt that first screaming run in the darkness, you'll be hooked for life.