%2Ffit-in%2F250x250%2Fguide_websites%2F18904%2Fimages%2F1726818384420temp_logos_sheet__4_-removebg-preview.png&w=1200&q=100)
Top-Rated Shark & Tarpon Fishing Key West
- Published Date: July 17, 2025
- Fishing
- Key West
- $499 - $999 price range
- Updated Date: November 16, 2025
Summary
%2F%2Fusers%2F198ba1d4-a1ae-41af-9e65-e08ae9dcc19e%2Fratecard%2Fscreenshot_5-2-2025_131856_www.instagram.com.jpeg&w=1200&q=75)
Night Sharks in Action
Night Shark Fishing: Key West's Twilight Thrill
Get ready for some serious after-hours action on the waters of Key West! This 4-hour private night fishing trip is all about chasing big game in the shadows. We're talking tarpon that'll make your arms ache, wily mangrove snapper, and the kings of the dark – blacktip and bull sharks. It's not your average day on the boat, folks. This is fishing with an edge, where every splash could be the next monster hit.
Trip Overview
We kick off at 4 PM, just as the sun starts to dip and the big boys come out to play. You and three buddies will hop aboard our 22' Lake and Bay boat – she's a beauty, built for these waters and comfortable enough to keep you fishing all night if we could. We're heading into Key West's backcountry, weaving through channels and posting up near bridges where the predators hunt. This isn't some lazy day of bottom fishing; we're going after the hard-fighters that make Key West famous. Whether you're a first-timer or a seasoned pro, our guides know how to put you on the fish and make sure you're having a blast doing it.
Night Moves: Tactics and Gear
Night fishing is a whole different ball game, and we've got it dialed in. We're using light tackle to feel every twitch and live bait to tempt those big predators. You'll be casting around structure, letting that bait dance in the current, and when a shark or tarpon hits – hold on tight! We provide all the gear, from rods to reels to bait, so you just need to bring your A-game. Our guides will show you the ropes if you're new, or swap stories and techniques if you're an old hand. It's all about reading the water, feeling the bite, and reacting fast when those monsters strike.
Species You'll Want to Hook
Tarpon: The "Silver King" is royalty in these waters. These prehistoric beasts can hit 50 pounds easy, and when they jump, it's like watching a bar of silver explode out of the water. They love to hunt at night, using their big eyes to spot prey. Tarpon put up a fight like you wouldn't believe – it's all thrashing head shakes and spectacular leaps. Landing one of these is a real notch in any angler's belt.
Blacktip Shark: These speedsters are the acrobats of the shark world. Blacktips are known for their explosive strikes and airborne antics. They'll hit your bait hard and fast, then take off on blistering runs that'll have your reel singing. Averaging around 5 feet, they're the perfect size for an exciting fight without being too overwhelming for newer anglers.
Lemon Shark: Don't let the name fool you – there's nothing sour about hooking one of these beauties. Lemon sharks are curious and crafty, often cruising in shallow waters. They've got a distinctive yellow-brown color that stands out even in the low light. These sharks can grow up to 10 feet long, so when you hook a big one, you're in for a serious tug-of-war.
Bull Shark: Now we're talking about the heavyweights. Bull sharks are the bruisers of the shallows, known for their stocky build and no-nonsense attitude. These guys can top 500 pounds and they've got the power to match. Hooking a bull shark is like trying to stop a freight train – it's all about patience, technique, and a little bit of luck. Landing one of these is a story you'll be telling for years.
Why Anglers Keep Coming Back
There's something special about fishing after dark in Key West. The water's calmer, the air's cooler, and there's this electric feeling of anticipation. You never know what's lurking just beyond the light of the boat. Our trips are private, so it's just you and your crew – no competing with strangers for the best spots. We keep things flexible, so if you want to focus on sharks or spend more time chasing tarpon, we can make it happen. It's your trip, after all.
Time to Book Your Spot
Look, Key West's got no shortage of fishing trips, but how many let you tangle with sharks and tarpon under the stars? This isn't just fishing; it's an adventure. Whether you're looking to scratch that fishing itch or want to give your vacation a shot of adrenaline, our night shark fishing trip is the ticket. Spots fill up fast, especially during peak seasons, so don't wait. Grab your crew, pick your date, and let's get you out on the water. Trust me, once you've felt that first night-time hit, you'll be hooked for life. Book now and get ready for a fishing story you'll actually want to tell!
Learn more about the animals
Blacktip Shark
Blacktips are one of our most common sharks around Key West, usually running 4 to 6 feet long. You'll spot them by the black tips on their fins, hence the name. These guys love warm, shallow water - we often find them patrolling near artificial reefs or in the backcountry. They're pretty active, known for leaping out of the water when chasing bait. Spring and summer are prime times to target blacktips. Anglers enjoy them for their quick runs and jumps once hooked. To catch one, try using oily fish like mackerel or sardines for bait. My local trick? Chum the water a bit to get them interested, then present a live bait. Just be ready - when they hit, it's usually fast and hard!
Bull Shark
Bull sharks are the heavyweights of our local shark scene, easily hitting 8 feet or more. These stocky predators are unique - they can handle both salt and fresh water, so you might spot them anywhere from the open ocean to way up coastal rivers. They're most active in the warmer months, especially around dawn and dusk. Bulls are known for their power and aggression, which makes for an intense fishing experience. Anglers love the challenge and the rush of reeling in such a formidable opponent. For bait, nothing beats a fresh-cut fish like mullet or jack. My go-to trick? Use a wire leader and let the bait sit on the bottom. Bulls often cruise low, looking for an easy meal. Just be ready for a fight when they strike!
Lemon Shark
Lemon sharks are a cool catch around Key West. They're usually 6 to 9 feet long, with a yellowish-brown color that gives them their name. You'll find these guys in shallow, coastal waters - they love hanging around mangroves and seagrass beds. Lemons are most active at night, which makes our evening trips perfect for targeting them. They're not as aggressive as some other sharks, but they put up a solid fight when hooked. Anglers dig them for their steady, powerful runs. To land one, try using fresh fish chunks or a live bait like a mullet. Here's a pro tip: when you feel the bite, give it a second before setting the hook. Lemons often grab the bait and run with it before fully committing.
Tarpon
Tarpon are real crowd-pleasers here in Key West. These silver kings can hit 100 pounds or more, and they're famous for their acrobatic jumps when hooked. You'll find them cruising the flats, channels, and around bridges, especially from spring through fall. They love to eat crabs, pinfish, and mullet. What makes tarpon fishing so exciting is the visual aspect - seeing a big one roll on the surface gets your heart racing. When you hook up, be ready for an intense fight. My tip? Let them run on that first big surge, then settle in for the long game. Patience is key with these prehistoric beauties. Just remember, we practice catch and release to keep the population healthy for years to come.
About the Key West Fishing Connection
%2F%2Fusers%2F198ba1d4-a1ae-41af-9e65-e08ae9dcc19e%2Fvehicle_picture%2F365968940_10227240736299201_3171697166667699204_n.jpg&w=1200&q=75)
Vehicle Guest Capacity: 4
Manufacturer Name: Yamaha outboard
Maximum Cruising Speed: 35
Number of Engines: 1
Horsepower per Engine: 250
